随笔 - 41  文章 - 29  trackbacks - 0
<2009年4月>
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293012
3456789

常用链接

留言簿(5)

随笔分类(28)

随笔档案(23)

收藏夹(6)

Inside JVM

Java

java performance

Solr

搜索

  •  

最新评论

阅读排行榜

评论排行榜

Currently, the major approach for java unit test are built on two major components –

  • Junit – The unit test framework
  • EasyMock and EasyMock Extension – Which are used to build mock test

What’s problem on Mock Test? It costs a lot time on preparation

Mock test is a very good way to test unit of codes. I still prefer mock test as the major approach of unit test. However, mock test has its own problem.

The major steps on Mock Test is –

  1. Assume we are going to test “Output ServiceA.MethodA(Input input)”, firstly, get an instance of ServiceA
  2. Create an Input for methodA, which generally need new an object and invoke many setter methods to set the values
  3. If this method will call ServiceB.MethodB, we need create a mock object for ServiceB, and create an ArugmentMather for methodB to match the arguments, and create a return object for methodB
  4. Then we invoke ServiceA.MethodA and internally ServiceA.MethodA will invoke ServiceB.MethodB, and finally, we get the Output object
  5. At the last step, we will assert the Output object.

In order to test ServiceA.MethodA, we did lots of things, and most of things are very time-consuming activities, such as

  • creating Input object,
  • creating Mock service,
  • creating ArgumentMacher for mock method, and
  • creating return object for mock method
  • And assert Output object

What’s my expectation?

  • creating Input object – Can it be created automatically?
  • creating Mock service – Can it be created automatically?
  • creating ArgumentMacher for mock method, and – Can we NOT need create a new class for it?
  • creating return object for mock method – Can it be created automatically?
  • And assert Output object – Instead of equals() method, can we compare two object by values?

How can Unitils help us?

Unitils is an open source library aimed at making unit testing easy and maintainable. Unitils builds further on existing libraries like dbunit and integrates with JUnit and TestNG .

Unitils provides general asserion utilities, support for database testing, support for testing with mock objects and offers integration with Spring , Hibernate and the Java Persistence API (JPA).

  • General testing utilities
    Equality assertion through reflection, with different options like ignoring Java default/null values and ignoring order of collections
  • EasyMock integration support
    • Simplify EasyMock mock object creation
    • Simplify mock object injection
    • EasyMock argument matching using reflection equality

Back to our problem –

  • Can we initialize a Input or Mock Method Returned Object automatically? In other words, creating an instance of a specific class, and fill all attributes by random values. Unfortunately, Unitils doesn’t have direct support on it. But i’ve created a simple util to initialize an bean based on Unitils.
1 //for BeanInitializer.initializeSimpleBean,  it is an simple tool to initialize a bean by random values. I didn't find a good tool for it, so, i write a simple one.
2 LogStatisticRawDataInput input = (LogStatisticRawDataInput) BeanInitializer.initializeSimpleBean(LogStatisticRawDataInput.class);
  • Can a mock object be created automatically? Yes, Unitils provides an annotation ”@ReguarMock” to support it
     1 public class SearchStatisticServiceImplTest extends com.starcite.commonsearch.test.Test {
     2 
     3     
     4 
     5     @RegularMock
     6 
     7     private StatisticAccess mockAccess; //just it
     8 
     9     
    10 
    11     private SearchStatisticService statisticService;
    12 
    13     
    14 
    15     @Before
    16 
    17     public void setUp() {
    18 
    19     statisticService = new SearchStatisticServiceImpl();
    20 
    21     ((SearchStatisticServiceImpl)statisticService).setStatisticAccess(mockAccess);
    22 
    23     }
    24 
    25     
    26 
    27     }
  • Can we compare the expected object and the real object by contents? Of course, no need write the equals by yourself. Yes, Unitils provides “Equality assertion through reflection, with different options like ignoring Java default/null values and ignoring order of collections”
    1     Map<String, Integer> expectedKeywordFreqMap = new HashMap<String, Integer>();
    2 
    3     Map<String, Integer> keywordFreqMap = output.getKeywordFreqMap();
    4     ReflectionAssert.assertReflectionEquals(expectedKeywordFreqMap, keywordFreqMap); //that's it
  • Can we create AugmentMatcher easier? Yes, Unitils provides “EasyMock argument matching using reflection equality”.
     1 //parameter matcher
     2 
     3     StatRawDataImpl rawData = new StatRawDataImpl();
     4 
     5     rawData.setKeyword(input.getKeyword());
     6 
     7     rawData.setLocation(input.getLocation());
     8 
     9     rawData.setAccountID(input.getUserID());
    10 
    11     rawData.setCreatedDate(new Date());
    12 
    13     rawData.setSiteID(input.getSiteID());
    14 
    15     rawData.setUniqueID(input.getSearchID());
    16 
    17 
    18     List<statsearchrank> searchRankList = new ArrayList</statsearchrank><statsearchrank>(); 
    19 
    20     for (int i = 0; i &lt; SEARCH_RESULT_SIZE; i++) {
    21 
    22            Long externalVendorID = searchResults.get(i);
    23 
    24            StatSearchRank rank = new StatSearchRankImpl();
    25 
    26            rank.setRank((input.getPageNum() - 1* //current page number
    27 
    28                               (input.getKeywordLocationPreferredSize() + input.getPageSize()) //total page size
    29 
    30                                                       + i + 1);
    31 
    32             rank.setExternalVendorID(externalVendorID);
    33 
    34             searchRankList.add(rank);
    35 
    36     }
    37 
    38     mockAccess.logStatisticRawData(
    39 
    40                 EasyMockUnitils.refEq(rawData, ReflectionComparatorMode.LENIENT_DATES), //that's it, no need argument matcher
    41 
    42                 EasyMockUnitils.refEq(searchRankList));
    43 
    44     EasyMock.expectLastCall().once();
    45 
    46     EasyMockUnitils.replay();
    47

Overall, Unitils  is a pretty good tool to simplify unit test codes. Here  we only mentioned Mock test, actually, Unitils can also simplify DB test/Spring Test etc. We will explore these futures later.
posted on 2009-03-30 22:30 Justin Chen 阅读(2000) 评论(1)  编辑  收藏 所属分类: Unit Test & Mock Test

FeedBack:
# re: [绝对原创] Use Unitils To Simplify Mock Test  2009-04-13 21:30 Justin Chen
Today, i took a look at another mock framework - JMockit (https://jmockit.dev.java.net/). The creator of JMockit claims "JMockit Core consists of a single class with a small set of static methods, which allow arbitrary methods and constructors of any other class to be replaced with mock implementations at runtime. "

It overcomes two limits comparing to EasyMock,
(1) mocked classes can't simply be instantiated with the new operator in client or test code.
(2) the classes to be mocked cannot be final

However, JMockit has its own limitation: the argument matcher provided by JMockit is not easy to use comparing to Unitils.  回复  更多评论
  

只有注册用户登录后才能发表评论。


网站导航: